by Jason Zuidema (ICMA)

At the recent Seafarers’ Welfare Conference organized by The Mission to Seafarers Australia in Adelaide, two presentations stood out for their candour and ambition. Samuel McSkimming, CEO of Pilbara Ports, and Phil Donnan, Manager of The Mission to Seafarers Port Hedland, offered a shared vision of renewal that moves seafarers’ welfare from charity to structured service, and from fragility to long term partnership.

McSkimming began with disarming honesty. Looking at the state of seafarers’ welfare in Port Hedland when he arrived, he said, “That’s not good enough at any port, and it’s certainly not good enough at one that I lead.” He described rusting signs on prime land that promised a future centre but delivered nothing, “silly fights” over who would pay for a bus to take seafarers to the supermarket, and a centre struggling after COVID with inconsistent volunteers and difficulty attracting chaplains to remote Australia. “I saw a port that felt it was doing the right thing simply because it managed each year to find its way to give people a Christmas hamper. That’s not good enough.”

For McSkimming, the solution was not more charity but a change in mindset. “We wanted to employ to this the language of business,” he said. “The seafarers are as an essential component of this port as any other service. They are as important as the pilot. They’re as important as the tug crew. They’re as important as the VTS officer, and they’re as important as the CEO of the Port Authority.” His reasoning was practical and direct. “A happy seafarer is a safe seafarer, and a safe seafarer is what I need to keep the port running.”

That conviction underpins the decision to fund and own a new seafarers’ centre costing $21 million dollars (AUD). The building will stand on secured land near the commercial jetty, beside the park where tourists gather to watch ships. “We want our seafarers’ centre to be at the centre of the port’s interaction between the port itself and its community,” he explained. “They don’t want to come ashore and sit in a room and play ping pong with each other. They want to come ashore and feel part of the greater human experience.”

The facility will include lounges, quiet zones, meditation areas, money changing, eastern style toilets, a chapel, WiFi, retail space, meeting rooms, and a commercial kitchen. Yet McSkimming was clear that bricks and mortar are not enough. “There are many white elephants that get built because people just think the building is enough, and the building is nothing without people in it.” Pilbara Ports will maintain the asset rather than pass on a liability.

More radical than the building is the funding model. “I’m not interested in providing welfare. I’m not a charity. I’m interested in running a business,” he said. The port is negotiating a long term services arrangement worth about $1.1 million dollars (AUD) per year over five years. “This isn’t a grant. It isn’t charity. We’re giving money because we want to buy services.” In return, the port expects defined service levels, open hours, chaplaincy presence, and reliable provision. “We impose port charges on people using our port to access the services that the port has available. And in my mind, it is as entirely reasonable to say that a vessel must pay for these activities as well.”

For the mission, this shift demands maturity and sustainability. “You can’t run a business off the back entirely of well meaning volunteers,” he observed. “Change is needed. What we’re doing now is not working.” Yet he ended with warmth and partnership, affirming that the relationship between the port and the mission has deepened “to one of mutual respect… where we change the game… to make lasting and meaningful difference.”

Phil Donnan then rose to speak from the Mission’s perspective. With humour he opened, “I’m sure the question on all your minds is, what are you going to do to get 1.1 million?” before reassuring the audience, “We don’t need to undress or sell our souls, so we do get to retain our logo and the mission of the society.”

He painted a vivid picture of life in Port Hedland. “We see 80,000 seafarers per year,” he said. Ships turn over rapidly, often alongside for only 24 to 36 hours. There is no pedestrian access from ship to town. “We have to pick up everyone with a launch.” The nearest shops are four kilometres away. “The seafarers’ centre has to provide everything.”

COVID hit hard. Shore leave numbers crashed from 2,500 a month to a few hundred. Volunteers disappeared. Chaplaincy had to be rebuilt. “After COVID we lost a lot of our staff and had to rebuild,” Donnan said. Even as operations recovered, patterns had changed. “Only about half the ships allow shore leave,” he noted. The future, he believes, lies in expanded ship visiting. “Ship visiting is absolutely critical for us.”

Donnan emphasised that hospitality alone is not enough. “While it’s great that we have hospitality and transport for our seafarers, that welfare is good. Pastoral care provides a degree of care that you can’t do just giving someone food and travel.” In one of the most memorable lines of the conference he said, “Welfare will fill some stomach and make them satisfied with where they’re at. Pastoral care gives them peace and joy beyond understanding.”

Recognising linguistic realities, the mission has prioritised multilingual chaplaincy and fly in fly out clergy. “To relate to someone in their own language connects on a level… that the best Aussie chaplain really can’t achieve.” Volunteers remain valued, but “depending on volunteers for the future is risky.” The partnership with Pilbara Ports allows the mission to professionalise while remaining faithful to its identity.

Donnan also described creative revenue streams such as harbour tours, ship visits for small groups, WiFi services to vessels at anchorage, and retail initiatives. Statistics, he said, were crucial in persuading the port to invest. “When they saw that kick in, the number of seafarers that we were supporting, they were prepared to engage further.”

Looking ahead, Donnan sees opportunity in the new centre and the structured agreement. The mission can expand hours, deepen chaplaincy, and demonstrate measurable impact. The port can show industry that seafarers are not an afterthought but an integral part of the maritime ecosystem.

Together, the two presentations offered more than funding news. They described a cultural shift. Seafarers are no longer recipients of occasional charity but partners in a service model grounded in dignity, safety, and mutual accountability. As McSkimming put it, “Even if you disagree with me, I ask that you see us doing something differently, because we see this as an issue of fundamental importance.” In Port Hedland, change is indeed afoot, and it is anchored in both business realism and pastoral conviction.